Buy on TCGplayer
Price
Create Commander Deck
Lock Printing
Love
Cool
Funny
Mean
Overplayed
Meh
Confusing
Hate
Commander Full Details
Nick Valentine, Private Eye
Legendary Artifact Creature — Synth Detective
#792 in this pool
CardChart.Fun shines when players can see how a card wins, loses, gets debated, and gets emotionally tagged across real community matchups.
13 votes in this pool4 top threads4 printings0 players built this commander
Current Pool Story
Nick Valentine, Private Eye is sitting at #792 with 2 wins, 11 losses, and 0 skips in the Commander pool.
Community Signal
This page tracks how players react, argue, and keep coming back to this card as the community signal grows.
All Magic Cards
Unranked
0% pick rate
Score
1,500
Votes
0
Wins
0
Losses
0
Skips
0
Pressure
0 passed
Just Commanders
#792
15% pick rate
Score
1,500
Votes
13
Wins
2
Losses
11
Skips
0
Pressure
11 passed
Community Feel
How Players Feel About This Card
0 total reactions
😍0
Loved
0% of reactions
😎0
Cool
0% of reactions
😂0
Funny
0% of reactions
😭0
Mean
0% of reactions
🙄0
Overplayed
0% of reactions
😐0
Meh
0% of reactions
😵💫0
Confusing
0% of reactions
🤬0
Hate
0% of reactions
Community Heat
Top 5 Community Pages Featuring This Card
Ranked by comment volume, participant depth, and activity
Debate0 comments
Obyra, Dreaming Duelist vs Nick Valentine, Private Eye
0 players joined in
Last active Apr 30, 2026Open Thread
Debate0 comments
Nick Valentine, Private Eye vs Galadriel, Gift-Giver
0 players joined in
Last active Apr 27, 2026Open Thread
Debate0 comments
Sauron, the Lidless Eye vs Nick Valentine, Private Eye
0 players joined in
Last active Apr 25, 2026Open Thread
Debate0 comments
Nick Valentine, Private Eye vs Brokkos, Apex of Forever
0 players joined in
Last active Apr 22, 2026Open Thread
Performance Pressure
Hardest Matchups
Cards that beat this one the most
Player Signal
Players Who Win With It
Top 5 users by wins in the active pool
Milestone Trail
First Votes and Growth Moments
Each milestone highlights logged-in community votes over time
1th community vote moment
by ekolimits
5th community vote moment
by thaumaturge