Buy on TCGplayer
Price
Create Commander Deck
Lock Printing
Love
Cool
Funny
Mean
Overplayed
Meh
Confusing
Hate
Commander Full Details
Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel
Legendary Creature — Siren Pirate
#92 in this pool
CardChart.Fun shines when players can see how a card wins, loses, gets debated, and gets emotionally tagged across real community matchups.
116 votes in this pool5 top debates4 printings😍 Loved leads with 10 players built this commander
Current Pool Story
Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel is sitting at #92 with 60 wins, 56 losses, and 0 skips in the Commander pool.
Community Signal
The strongest community mood right now is loved, and players have already pushed 5 standout debate threads involving this card.
All Magic Cards
Unranked
50% pick rate
Score
1,500
Votes
4
Wins
2
Losses
2
Skips
0
Pressure
2 passed
Just Commanders
#92
52% pick rate
Score
1,500
Votes
116
Wins
60
Losses
56
Skips
0
Pressure
56 passed
Community Feel
How Players Feel About This Card
2 total reactions
😍1
Loved
50% of reactions
😎0
Cool
0% of reactions
😂0
Funny
0% of reactions
😭0
Mean
0% of reactions
🙄0
Overplayed
0% of reactions
😐1
Meh
50% of reactions
😵💫0
Confusing
0% of reactions
🤬0
Hate
0% of reactions
Debate Heat
Top 5 Debate Pages Featuring This Card
Ranked by comment volume, participant depth, and activity
Debate2 comments
Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel vs Niv-Mizzet, Visionary
2 players joined in
niv ftw
Last active Apr 7, 2026Open Thread
Debate0 comments
Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel vs Jhoira, Weatherlight Captain
0 players joined in
Last active May 3, 2026Open Thread
Debate0 comments
Kirol, Attentive First-Year vs Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel
0 players joined in
Last active May 3, 2026Open Thread
Debate0 comments
Skrelv, Defector Mite vs Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel
0 players joined in
Last active May 3, 2026Open Thread
Debate0 comments
Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel vs Dragonlord Silumgar
0 players joined in
Last active May 3, 2026Open Thread
Performance Pressure
Hardest Matchups
Cards that beat this one the most
Player Signal
Players Who Win With It
Top 5 users by wins in the active pool
Milestone Trail
First Votes and Growth Moments
Each milestone highlights logged-in community votes over time
1th community vote moment
by ekolimits
5th community vote moment
by ekolimits
25th community vote moment
by Esoterica